The story behind "The Struggling Girl" which shook the whole world
Kevin
Carter took one of the historic pictures in history. The picture was
clicked in 1993 and he was awarded Pulitzer Prize for Feature
Photography in 1994. The image took the media by storm and still remains
one of the most influential photos ever taken.
The photograph is of a famine-stricken boy, who was initially believed to be a girl, starving to death with a vulture watching nearby. The picture tells a very sad story, and anyone who reads the story is sure to get his eyes wet. The tragedy portrayed by this photo goes beyond the picture itself.
The photograph is of a famine-stricken boy, who was initially believed to be a girl, starving to death with a vulture watching nearby. The picture tells a very sad story, and anyone who reads the story is sure to get his eyes wet. The tragedy portrayed by this photo goes beyond the picture itself.
During
1993, the parts of Sudan such as Kongor, Ayud, and Waat were much
affected by famine.The Hunger Triangle, a name relief organizations used
in the 1990s for the area defined by the South Sudan communities
Kongor, Ayod, and Waat, was dependent on UNESCO and other aid
organizations to fight famine. Forty percent of the area's children
under 5 years old were malnourished as of January 1993, and an estimated
10 to 13 adults died of starvation daily in Ayod alone.-[wiki]. As the
condition was severe, attempts were made to make this situation over the
world know about it. Photojournalists and other people were invited by
Operation Lifetime Sudan to light the extreme famine problem.
In
March 1993, Joao Silva and Kevin Carter were offered to visit Sudan
and report about famine and such similar problems hovering around those
places. The offer was made by Robert Hadley, a former photographer and
information officer for the UN Operation Lifeline Sudan at that time, in
March 1993. Carter and Silva decided to go because Silva thought it
would make him some kind of war photographer and for Carter, it was a
way to escape "the trapped feeling". Arrangements were made for the trip
and two enthusiastic photographers with their own imaginations on the
mind ,set to flew away towards the poverty struck part of Sudan.
Since
the problem of famine was high, there was constant fighting and blood.
The new fighting in Sudan forced them to wait in Nairobi for the period
of time. The next day the airplane landed in the tin hamlet of Ayod. The
villagers were already waiting for food in the runaway, as Marinvoich
wrote.
Both
Silva and Carter separated to take pictures of people, the mother, the
children and the adults, dead or alive or of those one fighting their
last battles, all victims of catastrophic famine that has arisen through
the war. Carter was shocked at the situation and he informed Silva that
witnessing the famine affected him emotionally. Silva, on the other
side, was searching for rebel soldiers so that he could have some
authority and when he found some such soldiers, Carter joined him too.
Since the soldier did not speak English, it was rather difficult to
communicate. One was constantly looking for Carter's watch, so Carter
gave him as a gift and the soldiers became their bodyguards and followed
them to their protection.
While
Carter was moving towards the runaway to click more images of
starvation, on his was he stopped several places to frame more of
images. He came across a child lying on his face in the hot sun - he
took the picture.
Carter
joined Silva in the runaway and told ""You won't believe what I've just
shot! … I was shooting this kid on her knees, and then changed my
angle, and suddenly there was this vulture right behind her! … And I
just kept shooting – shot lots of films![12] Silva asked him where he
shot the picture and was looking around to take a photo as well. Carter
pointed to a place 50 m (160 ft) away. Then Carter told him that he had
chased the vulture away. He told Silva he was shocked by the situation
he had just photographed, saying, "I see all this, and all I can think
of is Megan", his young daughter. A few minutes later they left Ayod for
Kongor.[13]
In
2011, the child's father revealed the child was actually a boy, Kong
Nyong, and had been taken care of by the UN food aid station. Nyong had
died four years prior, c. 2007, of "fevers", according to his family.
The striking part came afterward after the story was published in the "New York Times". The
image gathered a lot of criticisms, both positive and negative. People
argued that he should have helped the girl in rescuing her and other
congratulated him for his excellent shot. But the main story? Lies far
ahead.
He waited so Vulture could inch closer
Carter,
waited for about 20 minutes so that the Vulture would end up near the
poor child and even flap it's wings so that it would be a dramatic shot.
However, it did not happen and so Carter photographed the still image,
chased the vulture away and ran towards the runaway. He did not help the
child in any order and left the scene as it was, a hungry poor
miserable child on his face, on his way to the UN feeding center. As
Carter described, as the rampant situation, he did not find the
situation of the girl particularly unique.
But why?
In
Carter’s defense, photojournalists at that time were specifically
instructed not to touch famine victims due to the possibility of
spreading disease. There was little he could have done to help the girl,
but it was easy to judge someone who watched and took photographs while
a human being suffered. The revelation that Carter spent 20 minutes on
the scene certainly didn't help his reputation. Said the St. Petersburg
Times, “The man adjusting his lens to take just the right frame of her
suffering, might just as well be a predator, another vulture on the
scene.”
Still,
not all of the reaction to the photo was negative. Many praised it for
how powerfully and emotionally it captured the human suffering that was
occurring in South Sudan. No written description of the famine could
make so striking a point as this single picture. Kevin Carter was
awarded the Pulitzer Prize for the photo in 1994. He took his own life
shortly thereafter.[ranker]
More Tragedy afterward
At the age of 33, Carter drove
his car to a place where he used to play as a child, hooked a hose up to
his exhaust, and committed suicide via carbon monoxide poisoning. He
left behind a suicide note that said he was suffering from depression
and debt troubles and also mentioned the trauma he was experiencing from
a career of photographing horrible situations. He talked in the note of
“vivid memories of killings and corpses and anger and pain…of starving
or wounded children, of trigger-happy madmen, often police, of killer
executioners...”
The photograph
and the controversy surrounding it were added stress in a life full
spent capturing atrocities on camera. Kevin Carter's memory could not
erase the images he'd seen with his own eyes. It all added up, and
winning an award for one such haunting image likely only compounded the
guilt until Carter decided he'd had enough.[ranker]
0 comments